Locking Systems

A very important consideration when choosing a system is the locking mechanism. The rack itself should be the first line of defense against equipment theft. Both Yakima and Thule's systems provide lock sets with matching keys. Order as many lock cylinders as needed, and they'll all work with the same lock. (Remember to register the key number as soon as the packages arrive so that replacement keys or cylinders are never more than a phone call away.) Rhode Gear products don't feature an integrated locking system. While it won't provide the same level of security, you can add a cable lock or hitch mount lock (depending on your model) from a company such as Kryptonite, which specializes in offering locks for just about everything and has devices that work with hitches or wrap around roof racks for extra protection.

Installation

Finding a local dealer who can help with selection and installation is very important. Generally speaking, the installation instructions for a well-built rack system are more than sufficient to guide all but the most technically incompetent provided the directions are followed exactly, but guidance from an expert is sometimes a lifesaver. Over the years I've installed quite a number of racks and accessories on my own, and sometimes I skim the directions. As a result I've had to (on more than one occasion) go back and start a step from the beginning to fix a mistake. Even though the kits usually pack all the tools they need, have a good set of Allen wrenches on hand. Nothing's worse than trying to put together something with a little Ikea-esque tool. Most bike stores will help customers, as will larger sport specialty stores, like REI, that boast installation centers in many locations. Shopping

A number of Web sites and mail-order houses sell rack systems directly to the consumer. There is an upside and a downside to this availability. Thanks to a lack of overhead, many direct sales sites can offer lower prices than those of retailers. The downside is that there's no one to help you make sure the kit fits the car. It never hurts to support the local bike dealer anyhow. The Yakima and Thule Web sites can locate the closest dealer, who can special order any parts that aren't in stock. Rhode Gear offers no dealer locator, but does provide a number of links to stores that carry their products.

Brand Comparison

Both Yakima and Thule offer complete systems that will run less than $600 for a roof rack or less than $500 for a hitch mount. After years of playing with racks, I've always found Yakima kits easier to install, and, honestly, sharper looking. Yakima tends toward rounded svelte components, while Thule's equipment tends toward square designs.

While the Yakima is my choice for rack systems (ten years without any problems is my idea of good product design), the decision comes down to a matter of personal taste and dealer availability. A good rack system should last a lifetime, so invest wisely, steer clear of bargain systems, and think about growing the system to include more bikes or more hobbies.

When selecting a rack, spend as much time as possible on the Web sites of Yakima and Thule. These two companies are the leaders in the industry, and for good reason. Their products are strong, well built, and backed by impressive warranties and customer service. Both offer very similar systems, at very similar price points. Users of both Yakima and Thule are fanatical in their devotion to the products, which indicates that both systems are worth the money.

Back to Introduction

Return to Top

RELATED GORP LINKS
GORP Biking
GORPgear
GORPtravel